In the pantheon of sci-fi action, few creatures are as iconic as the Yautja—better known as the Predator. So when director Shane Black, who had a small acting role as Hawkins in the original 1987 Predator , was tapped to reboot the franchise in 2018, expectations were cautiously high. Black was known for sharp dialogue, buddy-cop dynamics, and subversive action. The result, simply titled The Predator , became one of the most turbulent and debated entries in the franchise’s history.
Upon release in September 2018, The Predator was savaged by critics and received a lukewarm response from audiences. On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds a 33% approval rating, with the consensus calling it "a messy, frantic, and ultimately forgettable addition to the franchise." Fans were divided: some appreciated the dark humor and gory kills, while others derided the convoluted plot, the underwhelming "Upgrade" Predator design, and the tonal whiplash between slapstick comedy and extreme violence. predator -2018-
For years, the franchise lay dormant. The 2018 film is now viewed by many as a well-intentioned misfire—a film where a talented director tried to reinvent a classic but got lost in studio interference, bad luck, and a script that tried to do too much at once. It wasn't until the surprise success of Prey (2022), a smaller, more focused prequel set in the Comanche Nation, that the Predator franchise found its footing again. In comparison, Prey ’s lean, brutal efficiency only highlighted the bloated, confused ambition of The Predator (2018). It remains a cautionary tale: sometimes, the most dangerous enemy isn’t the alien with the plasma caster—it’s a studio with too many notes. In the pantheon of sci-fi action, few creatures
More damaging was a controversy that erupted just before release. Black had cast his close friend, Steven Wilder Striegel, in a small, non-speaking role as a leering prisoner. Striegel was a registered sex offender following a 2010 conviction for luring a 14-year-old girl online. When Olivia Munn discovered this, she confronted the studio, and the scene was removed from the final film. The incident cast a long shadow over the movie’s marketing. The result, simply titled The Predator , became