Very few games have made me question my own agency like that. It turned a standard "rescue the princess" fetch quest into a philosophical debate about determinism. Bioshock isn't a jumpscare game (though the Houdini Splicers got me twice). It’s a "slow dread" game.
Shooting bees out of your wrist never gets old. Setting a trail of oil on fire to fry a group of Splicers is deeply satisfying. Electrocuting a puddle of water is a cheap trick, but it works every time. bioshock 1
Warning: Light spoilers for the opening hour of BioShock (2007) below. Very few games have made me question my own agency like that