The magazine even included a perforated “Digital Detox Bingo Card” – squares included “Checked phone during a conversation,” “Instagrammed your food,” and “Googled an ex.” The fact that Instagram was only six weeks old in November 2010 makes this card astonishingly forward-thinking.

In the end, 18 Eighteen folded in 2012, a casualty of the very digital wave it had tried to critique. But the November 2010 issue remains a time capsule: a reminder that sometimes, the most important stories aren’t about what’s new, but about what’s true.

Today, original copies sell for over $50 on eBay—not for their ads (which feature now-defunct brands like Borders and Blockbuster), but because for a generation currently in their late twenties and early thirties, that issue was the first time they felt seen .